26 replies to this topic

[LCF-AT]

Hello,

so yesterday I installed VirtualBox-4.1.6-74713-Win.exe on my system after a long time again. Also installed win2000 SP4 and also the VirtualBox Guest Additions which was to find in the VBox folder.All seems to be fine but then after some tests I got this problems.

- HWBPs does not work in Olly
- Scrolling in Olly hangs and is very slow | if I try to move the dump window higher or lower then its really nasty
- Olly can't read some Olly plugins

Ok I have seen that the HWBP problem was already fixed in a older VBox version but now I have the problem in this new version.The question now is whether this version is the problem or something else!?!

Now the plugins.So I just want to use the ODBGScript plugin with Olly and I have test both from the package ODBGScript.dll <-- does not work and then the ODbgScript_Win2k.dll which should work with win2000 but surprise Olly does not accept this plugin too in the plugin menu!Then I found a older a ODbgScript_Win2k.dll version which Olly has accept [no idea why] but if I open the script window then I see a yellow exclamation mark on the window left above.Also this script is a older version and does not support all commands.So normaly I want to use a latest script version 1.82.6 | 1.83 + but they don't work!

So what can I do now?So if you know a solution how to fix these problems [need HWBPs + new Script solution] then tell me please.So I can't remember what I had done the last time where I had used VBox before a few years.I hope that you have some hints for me.So I don't belive that the VBox maker have forgotten to add the HWBP bug in this new version but I don't know it.

Thanks

[NullPointerException]

I had the same problem with hardware bp in virtualbox in the past with a different version.
I have never solved it even after upgrading to newer versions altough some people claims that it worked for them.
My opinion is that it's a matter of hardware. Are you running virtual box in a old pc?

Hate to say but sometimes free software is not the best especially for re tasks, consider to switch to vmware. i can assure you that with the old workstation 6.5 i had never a problem with hwbp or virtualkd.

[LCF-AT]

Hi NullPointerException,

uhhmm this sound very BAD! So I have seen that the HWBP issue was fixed since version 2.x in a changelog and now you tell me this bad news.Hhhmmm.So I also installed a 2. vdi with Windows XP to check whether the HWBPs are working on this OS but also the same on XP,no HWBPs are working.Great,big installing of all stuff + a lot time waste and now this!So I can really hope that someone has maybe a solution for this HWBP problem in VBox if not then I can throw all into the trash again.

So about VMWare.I tried this also in the past [1 time VM] but this app is very large [if I remember right] and works also slower on my system than VBox [if I remember right again] or it was other way around [if I remember right this time]. So I see that VBox eat a lot system resources and switching of all panels [all open app etc] of all [main OS & VBox itself] takes a lot time and hangs in the bad case for 30 sec and more and this is also a bad thing = my system is too low to handle them all at the same time.

Ah ok and thanks so far for the info N:P:E so I will wait a while and see what the other members have to tell about this problem.Maybe someone brings the light for me.

PS: Yes I use a older PC.P-III with under 1 Ghz.

greetz

[Nacho_dj]

Hey mate, please read this ticket log about this bug, here you should find the answer:

https://www.virtualbox.org/ticket/477#comment:36

I hope you will get now HBPX working...

Cheers

Nacho_dj

[NullPointerException]

Quote

PS: Yes I use a older PC.P-III with under 1 Ghz.

Then it's an hardware virtualization problem. Pheraps your processor is not properly supported by virtualbox ie virtualbox cannot access some features in you cpu. are you sure that hw bp worked for you in the same pc with older versions of virtualbox? Again, a commercial app like vmware might take care of a wider family of cpu.
i have your same problem with low resources but i can handle 1 vm running with xp in a old vmware. Not sure what you want to achieve.

[LCF-AT]

@ Nacho_dj

Hhmm so do you mean I should try to install version 3.2.12?

Or

"Enable hardware virtualization, hardware breakpoints in OllyDbg? now work." =?Is there a option in Olly to enable this?I only can see this in Olly to set...

Debug:
"Use hardware breakpoints to step or trace code"

@ NullPointerException

Thats the problem so I can't remember whether the HWBPs was working for me with the older version before a few years.So I think yes but I don't know it anymore for 100% you know.Ok if you have also a low PC and your VM works normaly then it was maybe so that VMWare was faster than VBox with the main handling.

greetz

[GaBoR]

I've tested on an Athlon II X2 245 running Windows 7 Pro 32bit, Windows 2000 VM, if I disable AMD-V, hwbp's don't work anymore.
I think your processor doesn't support hardware virtualization such as Intel VT-x or AMD-V, if it supports any of them then you should be
able to enable it in VirtualBox, select your VM, go to Settings->System->Acceleration & see there if there's available.
I think you need to upgrade, but you've probably heard that before . I had to use a Pentium II until 2006, when I upgraded.

Edited by GaBoR, 12 November 2011 - 07:56 AM.

[LCF-AT]

@ GaBoR

VirtualBox, select your VM, go to Settings->System->Acceleration = GHOST Your are right so its disables for me.Cant choose this register card.Sh...t!

So must I swtich now to VMWare yes?Is it also sure that this tool supports HWBPs also on my low system?Just need to know this now for 100% before installing all this stuff again you know.

greetz

[Nacho_dj]

LCF-AT, if you are running an XP OS, you can install Virtual PC or vmware. Both of them will allow HWBP on your machine.

I use all of the three VM, and I can confirm this.

Cheers

Nacho_dj

[LCF-AT]

@ Nacho_dj

Ok Virtual PC or VMWare + XP.Thanks for the info.So at the moment I have enough of VBox.So I will test now Virtual PC so I see it has also just a size of 30+ MB and VMWare more than 500 MB!So I hope that Virtual PC also supports the OS vdi file of VBox if not then I have to install the OS again.I will see and report then the news after installing & testing.

greetz

[GaBoR]

You could try VMware Player too, the installer is 116 MB, installed occupies around 188MB, you can create new vm's, edit vm settings, etc:
http://www.softpedia...re-Player.shtml

[deepzero]

for older hw i can really reccomend MS Virtual PC 2007.
Back when i used a pIII cpu, hwbps were working for me. (although it was a pretty good pIII).
Performance of the host system was OK, too.

I would also reccomend to use XP, not 2000. Much better support from all sides: rce tools, security updates,....

Right now i am running a XPSP3 system on VirtualPC on a p4 1,8 ghz machine....everyting works perfectly fine.


edit:
asides that, you should really upgrade. Is this just your reversing PC? (if so, why not install a VM on your main system?)
If that pIII > 1ghz is your main machine, check you local junkyard, with a little luck, you find better stuff there.
(this is where i got my pIII (~1,5 ghz) from, and that was some years ago...)

Edited by deepzero, 12 November 2011 - 06:21 PM.

[LCF-AT]

Hi all,

@ GaBoR

Ok so is this player working like VMWare?Or can I use this player alone without other VM stuff etc?

@ deepzero

Yes upgrade is a good idea. No its my all in one PC.Just use this one.I call it the "time eater" Just eat my time with only waiting for everything.Spend more time with waiting than everything else.

ok now I installed Virtual PC 2007.What happend?

1. Crash durring installing!Anyway.
2. Installing XP SP 0 or 1 // No SP2 or SP3 - Need a lot time to install the OS so VBox has installed the OS very faster!Anyway.Also here crash on installing XP of my main OS again! = 2 times big crash!Anyway.
3. Load XP OS.Seems to fine and performance is also very faster and better than VBox.
4. Install additions VMAdditions.iso
5. Restart and now.....screen has a 4 bit colour sheme with the videodriver from the VMAdditions!=?Can not set it higher so there is nothing to choose!
6. Diable video driver and now it loads without video but now I can choose all 32 bit & 1024x ... and more!?!
7. Ok I let it so and test Olly now.Copy my Olly in shared folder and copy Olly to new OS.Setup ini paths and start.What happend?Yeah another crash = strongOD driver trash.Ok now I use clean Olly + strongOD with kernelmode.Now Olly starts but no driver was loaded!Hmmmmmmm!!!MMMHHHMMmmm!So ne sch.... hier!Ok now I test Olly + TM app & notepad too.I trace over command = app terminated!What is this?

Push xxxxx = Olly Terminated
Pushad = Terminated
sub esp, -4 = Terminated

Ooohhhhhh!

Ok,restart the trash open Olly load notepad and run ahhhhh now it works. But then after a while and reloading any app I got the same trouble.So why does it just terminate if it wants to execute a simple command?

Other problem is that I can not change the VirtualPC window manually with mouse.So I can make it smaller but not higher and also a auto window snap / adjust is also not to see.So VBox had such feature.Ahh,hardware BPs are working in V-PC. This is the best message which I can tell you but the rest seems to make a lot trouble but I dont know why.

So can you tell me what I have done wrong and what I can do to fix this video driver,push terminate and crash problems?Need some infos.

Ah,is there also a way to increase the vhd file?So I have enter a size of 1.3 GB at the beginning and now its has a size of 1298777 KB already.

PS: Virtual Disk Precompactor.iso <--- Should I install this too?Ah and there is also a strange size showing in the explorer in the VM.So it shows me almost 12 GB of free size?!?Why this?Seems also be a error or something.

greetz

[Nacho_dj]

A very good advantage of Virtual PC is it allows drag&drop from outside to the inside of the VM and viceversa...

I hope it will work fine for you. I use it on W2K as host, and in another machine with XP sp3 as host. Both of them go fine!

Good luck with your tests

Kind regards

Nacho_dj

[GaBoR]

Yes, it's working like VMWare. VMware Player is a stripped down Vmware Workstation.
From vmware site:

Quote

Do I need another VMware product to use VMware Player?

No. VMware Player enables you to create and run virtual machines. However, if you need to leverage powerful developer-centric features such as Teams, multiple Snapshots and Clones, or Virtual Rights Management features for end-point security, you will need to upgrade to VMware Workstation.

On softpedia site it says it requires :

Quote

· 64-bit x86 CPU
· LAHF/SAHF support in long mode

So your PIII is most likely not compatible.
I suggest buying this computer from ebay:
http://www.ebay.de/i...=item2315e1782f
Or if you don't have that amount of money here are some cheaper alternatives:
http://www.ebay.de/i...=item2c608f2a7d
http://www.ebay.de/i...=item43aaeb0a1f
http://www.ebay.de/i...=item3cbd823e9a

[deepzero]

jesus, the prices went down sincei checked ebay the last time... O_O

[LCF-AT]

Hi again,

ok I will test your VMWPlayer now maybe this will work better than with V PC.Also I dont know why V PC makes this trouble so VBox was working good with the same XP OS + my Olly & StrongOD just HWBPs was not working and in V PC HWBPs are working but the rest not.

Thanks also for the links GaBoR so I see they dont cost too much. I will see but normaly I dont need a new PC.But will think about it.

greetz

[deepzero]

Quote

I will see but normaly I dont need a new PC

ah, for a long time i said this about my hopelessly overclocked amd k-5 cpu...
Back in the day when my GPU was faster than my CPU...

I then upgraded over a pIII to the 1,8 ghz p4 i have now and it was...awesome! totally worth the upgrade! Go for it!

[LCF-AT]

Hhmmm I can not install the VMWPlayer!
Great!I use XP SP3.

1 GHz or faster = no
1GB RAM minimum = no
150MB of disk space = yes
-----------------------------
What now?

greetz

Attached Thumbnails

• 

[Killboy]

Quote

What now?

Get a new PC...
The minimum hardware specs are there for a reason. Your specs were OK back in 2000 or something.
I realize some can afford a faster PC and some can't or refuse to. Either way, there's not much else you can do.